Today's KNOWLEDGE Share : PIGMENT DISPERSION IN COATINGS | PART 5
Today's KNOWLEDGE Share
PIGMENT DISPERSION IN COATINGS | PART 5
Hegman Grind vs. Particle Size: Are We Measuring the Same Thing?
A good Hegman reading does not necessarily mean a pigment dispersion has reached its optimum particle size distribution.
These methods assess different aspects of dispersion quality.
1. What does the Hegman gauge actually measure?
The Hegman grind gauge is a practical quality-control tool for evaluating dispersion fineness in coatings. It helps identify coarse particles & agglomerates that produce visible traces as the sample is drawn down across a calibrated groove.
However, it does not measure the complete particle size distribution or directly quantify dispersion stability. A satisfactory reading does not describe the entire pigment population.
2 .What do instrumental methods add?
Modern particle characterization techniques provide complementary information:
Laser Diffraction (LD)
Measures particle size distribution over a broad range. It is useful for evaluating coarse populations & changes in agglomerate size.
Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS)
Estimates hydrodynamic particle size in suitable dilute dispersions, particularly in the submicron and nanoscale range. Results are sensitive to larger particles & sample preparation.
Optical and Electron Microscopy
Allow direct visualization of particle morphology depending on resolution & preparation, aggregates/ agglomerates. SEM & TEM reveal structural details that a grind gauge cannot.
Analytical Centrifugation
Helps characterize sedimentation behavior & dispersion stability by monitoring concentration profiles over time.
Each technique answers a different question; selection depends on pigment type, formulation & the information required.
3. Why can the results differ?
A grind gauge and a particle size analyzer do not measure exactly the same property.
For example, a dispersion may achieve a satisfactory Hegman reading while laser diffraction still detects a broader coarse-particle or agglomerate population.
Results can also change with dilution, dispersion energy & sample preparation.
The measurement method must match the question being asked.
4. What should formulators evaluate?
A more complete assessment combines complementary measurements:
• Hegman: coarse-particle control
• Particle size distribution: size range & distribution profile
• Microscopy: morphology and structural features
• Storage testing: changes over time
• Viscosity & color strength: formulation performance
The objective is not to replace a simple, effective quality-control tool with a more sophisticated instrument in every case. It is to understand what each measurement can—and cannot—tell us.
Sample preparation & measurement conditions should therefore be standardized before comparing results.
A single measurement cannot fully describe dispersion quality.
The best evaluation combines the right analytical methods with actual coating performance.
source : Ernesto Muñiz Mata

Comments
Post a Comment